Last updated: August 21, 2026
Most people buy a feeder first and find out afterward which birds it serves. That is backwards, and it is why so many yards end up with three feeders that all attract the same four species while the cardinals stay in the hedge and the woodpeckers never come at all. The shape of a feeder is a filter, and the filter is set before you fill it.
This page is the one table version of that. It pairs each common feeder design with the food it holds, the birds that use it, and what it quietly leaves out, using the descriptions Project FeederWatch publishes rather than anything invented here. Read the row that matches the bird you want, then buy the feeder in that row.
This article contains affiliate links. If you buy through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more.
Quick Answer
Which feeder attracts which bird?
- Hoppers and trays attract the widest range, big birds included.
- Tubes with short perches attract small birds and exclude grackles and jays.
- Suet cages attract woodpeckers, nuthatches and chickadees.
- Nyjer feeders attract goldfinches, siskins and redpolls, and almost nothing else.
Bottom line: pick the row that matches the bird you want, because the feeder shape decides the guest list before the seed does.
The Table
Here is the whole answer in one place. The feeder behavior and the food associations come from Project FeederWatch, the winter feeder survey run by the Cornell Lab of Ornithology, which publishes descriptions of each feeder type and each common food along with the birds they draw.
| Feeder | What goes in it | Birds that use it | What it leaves out |
|---|---|---|---|
| Large hopper | Black oil sunflower, mixes | Most feeder birds, doves and grackles included | Very little |
| Small hopper | Sunflower, mixes | Smaller birds | Larger species cannot perch comfortably |
| Tube, short perches | Sunflower, hearts | Finches, chickadees, titmice, nuthatches | Grackles and jays |
| Tray or platform | Sunflower, mixes, fruit | Most feeder birds | Almost nothing |
| Tray placed near the ground | Millet, cracked corn, sunflower | Juncos, doves, sparrows | Nothing, but it feeds rodents too |
| Suet cage, open sides | Suet cakes | Woodpeckers, nuthatches, chickadees | Nothing, starlings included |
| Suet cage, bottom access | Suet cakes | Woodpeckers, nuthatches, chickadees | Starling resistant |
| Nyjer feeder, small ports | Nyjer only | American Goldfinch, Pine Siskin, Common Redpoll | Nearly everything else |
| Caged tube | Sunflower, hearts | Chickadees, finches, titmice, nuthatches | Grackles, jays, doves, squirrels |
| Peanut feeder, mesh or wire | Peanuts, shelled or in shell | Jays, chickadees, nuthatches, titmice, woodpeckers | Most seed only birds |
| Oriole feeder | Nectar, jelly, orange halves | Orioles, sometimes catbirds and woodpeckers | Seed eating birds |
Two clarifications on the rows above. Starling resistant is the wording Project FeederWatch uses for bottom access suet cages, and resistant is the accurate word: it reduces the problem rather than ending it. And the oriole row sits outside the seed feeder logic entirely, because those birds come for fruit and sugar rather than seed.
How to Read the Table
Work backwards from the bird. Decide which species you actually want in the yard, find it in the third column, and buy the feeder in that row. That is a completely different process from browsing feeders and hoping, and it is the reason most experienced feeders end up with two or three different shapes rather than three of the same one.
Then look at the fourth column and decide whether you can live with it. Excluding grackles usually means excluding cardinals too. Feeding doves at ground level usually means dealing with what else visits the ground. Those trades are the real content of the table.
Why Two Feeders Beat One
Almost every yard is better served by a hopper and a tube on separate hooks than by one large feeder. The hopper takes the standing birds and the tube takes the clinging ones, nothing crowds anything, and you can move one without losing the other. The shape by shape comparison is in hopper, tube or platform.
The Food Column, in a Little More Detail
Project FeederWatch describes black oil sunflower as high in energy with thin shells, which makes it the preferred item for a wide variety of birds including cardinals, chickadees, finches and sparrows, with occasional woodpeckers. If you only ever buy one seed, that is the one.
The rest are specialists. Nyjer draws finches and needs a feeder with small ports. Safflower attracts cardinals and other big billed birds, though Project FeederWatch notes most birds prefer sunflower over it. Cracked corn attracts doves, quail and sparrows, and millet is described as a favored food of many smaller ground foraging birds. Suet is a good choice for attracting insect eating birds.
Peanuts Behave Differently
Peanuts sit across two rows. Project FeederWatch notes that jays may grab several peanuts at a time and fly off to hide them, while shelled peanuts suit chickadees, nuthatches and titmice. So one food serves two groups, and which one you see depends on whether you offer them whole or shelled.
What the Table Cannot Tell You
It cannot tell you which birds live near you. A perfect nyjer feeder in a yard with no goldfinches within a mile will sit untouched, and no amount of equipment fixes that. Cornell’s All About Birds range maps and eBird are the practical way to find out what is realistic where you are before you spend anything.
It also cannot tell you about placement, which changes behavior almost as much as the feeder does. Cardinals want cover nearby, crows want open sightlines, nuthatches want a trunk. A feeder in the wrong place underperforms a cheaper one in the right place, reliably.
And It Cannot Solve Squirrels
Only one row in the table addresses them, and only partly. Squirrel management is a separate question of poles, distances and baffles, and it is covered properly in squirrel resistant feeders and baffles.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which feeder attracts the most species? A large hopper or a tray. Project FeederWatch says large hoppers attract most species of feeder birds and allow larger species like doves and grackles to feed, and that tray feeders also attract most species of feeder birds.
Which feeder attracts woodpeckers? A suet cage. Project FeederWatch names woodpeckers, nuthatches and chickadees as the birds that feed from bottom access suet cages, and describes suet as a good choice for attracting insect eating birds. Details in our suet feeder guide.
What feeder do cardinals prefer? One with somewhere to stand: a hopper with a ledge or a tray. Project FeederWatch lists cardinals among the birds black oil sunflower attracts, and separately notes that safflower attracts cardinals and other big billed birds. See the cardinal feeder guide.
Which feeder keeps grackles out? A tube with short perches. Project FeederWatch describes that design as accommodating small birds such as finches while excluding larger birds such as grackles and jays. A caged tube is the stronger version of the same idea.
Do I need a separate feeder for goldfinches? For nyjer, yes, because it needs small ports. Goldfinches also take sunflower, so a standard tube covers them too. The trade offs are in the goldfinch feeder guide.
How many feeders should a yard have? Two or three of different shapes, spread out rather than clustered. Spacing them reduces crowding, and different shapes cover different birds, which is the entire point of the table above.
The Bottom Line
The feeder shape sets the guest list and the seed fine tunes it. Decide which birds you want, read across the row, and buy that feeder rather than the one on offer. Most yards land on a hopper for the standing birds, a short perched or caged tube for the small ones, and a suet cage for the bark feeders. If you are starting from nothing, hopper, tube or platform is the place to begin, and if a particular species is the goal, the cardinal and suet feeder guides go a level deeper.